🎉 Celebrate with 10% OFF on All Products! Use Code: GFEX10 Or Buy Any 2+ Items for 30% OFF with Code: GFEX30!
Guides & Tutorials November 1, 2026

How to Match Mentors and Mentees with Gravity Forms (Scored, Explained, Within Capacity)

GravityExtra
How to Match Mentors and Mentees with Gravity Forms (Scored, Explained, Within Capacity)

Every mentoring programme starts with the same job: deciding who should mentor whom. With ten people it is a pleasant afternoon. With sixty mentees and twenty-five mentors it becomes a week of reading two spreadsheets side by side, trying to remember who speaks Spanish, who is in finance, who said they could take two people and who lives eight hours away. Then come the introduction e-mails, the chasing, the people who never reply and the pairs that quietly stop meeting.

If your website runs Gravity Forms, the whole process can move onto it: a profile form for mentors, an application form for mentees, scored suggestions with the reasons behind them, introductions with accept and decline links, and check-ins that tell you which pairs need help. This guide walks through what good matching needs and then sets it up step by step with the Gravity Forms Mentor Matching add-on.

Why matching by hand breaks down

  • It does not scale. Sixty mentees and twenty-five mentors make 1,500 possible pairs. Nobody compares them all, so the first reasonable pair wins.
  • It is hard to explain. When a mentee asks why they got a particular mentor, “it felt right” is not a great answer, and a new coordinator cannot repeat it.
  • Mentors get overloaded. The most popular mentor ends up with four mentees after saying they could take two.
  • Hard rules get missed. A mentee who needs a Spanish-speaking mentor, or one within a few hours of their time zone, gets someone who cannot help.
  • Introductions stall. Contact details go out before both sides agree, or nobody notices that a mentor never answered.
  • Nobody follows up. Without regular check-ins you find out at the end of the year that half the pairs met once.

What good mentor matching needs

  • The same questions asked of both sides, so answers can be compared: topics, skills, language, industry, experience, availability and time zone.
  • Weights, because sharing topics usually matters more than sharing an industry, and some rules (a common language, a workable time zone) must simply hold.
  • A score for every pair and a plain-language reason, so coordinators can trust it and explain it.
  • A hard limit on how many mentees each mentor takes, even when two coordinators confirm at the same moment.
  • A human in the loop: coordinators should be able to swap and override pairs, with a warning when they break a rule.
  • A clear introduction with consent from both sides before any contact details are shared.
  • Check-ins at set times, and a dashboard that shows who is matched, who is waiting, who is unmatched and which pairs have ended.

Step 1: build the two forms

Create a Mentor profile form and a Mentee application form. Ask the same matching questions on both with the same choices: checkboxes or a multi select for topics, drop downs for language and industry, checkboxes for availability and a drop down for time zone with the UTC offset at the start (“UTC-5 (New York)”). On the mentor form, add a number field for years of experience and one for “How many mentees can you take?”. On the mentee form, ask what experience they want (Any, 5-10, 10+, 15+). Give the mentee form an “Any” choice where people may not mind.

Step 2: map the fields and set the criteria

In Forms → Mentor Matching → Setup, choose both forms, map the name, e-mail, phone and capacity fields and add one criterion row per question. A good starting point for a university alumni programme:

  • Topics, shared items, weight 4.
  • Industry, same value, weight 2.
  • Language, same value, weight 2, must match.
  • Experience, number in range, weight 1, tolerance 5 years.
  • Availability, availability overlap, weight 1.
  • Time zone, hours apart, weight 1, must match within 3 hours.

Leave the minimum score at 30 to begin with and the check-in days at 14, 45 and 90.

The Setup tab: programme name and team e-mail, places per mentor, minimum score and check-in days, the mentor and mentee forms with their name, e-mail, phone and capacity fields, and six matching criteria with type, mentor field, mentee field, weight, must match and setting
Forms → Mentor Matching → Setup: two forms, the contact fields and the criteria with their weights.

Step 3: read the suggestions and the reasons

Open the Suggestions tab. Each mentee has a suggested mentor, a score out of 100 and a “why” list: every criterion with its points and a reason such as 2 of 3 shared: Finance, Leadership, Both: Spanish or 3 h apart. Suggestions never break a must-match rule and never give a mentor more mentees than they offered to take. The add-on starts with the best-scoring pairs and then improves the result, for example by moving one mentee to another mentor with room so that a second mentee can be placed.

Mentees who cannot be placed are listed with the reason. “The 1 mentor who fits is at capacity” means you need another mentor for that profile. “No mentor meets the must-match rules: Language (4 of 4 mentors differ)” means nobody speaks the language the mentee needs. Those reasons turn into a recruiting list.

The Suggestions tab: each mentee with the suggested mentor, a score out of 100 and a why list with points per criterion, plus two mentees who were not matched with the reason
Suggested pairs with the score and the reasons behind it. Mentees who could not be placed are listed with the reason.

Step 4: adjust, then confirm

Change a mentor in any row, or swap the mentors of two rows. The pair is scored again on the spot. If you break a must-match rule, you see a red warning and have to press Confirm anyway; the pair is then marked as an override so everyone can see it was a deliberate choice. Capacity is the one thing you cannot override: each confirm takes a mentor place in a single database step, so two coordinators confirming at the same moment cannot overfill a mentor.

An override in the suggestions table: a mentee given to a different mentor, the new score and a red warning that the Language must-match rule is broken, with a Confirm anyway button
Changing a mentor re-scores the pair. Breaking a must-match rule needs a second, deliberate click.

Step 5: introductions with consent

Both people get an introduction e-mail with the other’s first name, the reasons for the match and accept and decline links signed just for them. The link opens a short page where they press Accept or Decline. Contact details are shared only when both have accepted: then each side gets the other’s name, e-mail and phone. If either side declines, the mentee goes back to the pool, the mentor’s place is freed and the programme team gets a note; the same pair is not suggested again.

Step 6: check-ins and the dashboard

At 14, 45 and 90 days (or the days you choose) both sides get a one-minute check-in: a rating from 1 to 5, an optional note and a tick box to ask for help. The dashboard shows matched, waiting for reply, unmatched and ended pairs, each mentor’s places, and the check-ins with a low rating or a request for help. When a pair finishes, end the match: the date is recorded and the mentor is free for the next mentee. A CSV export gives you the whole programme for your annual report.

The programme dashboard: counts of matched, waiting for reply, unmatched and ended, mentor capacity bars and a check-in that asks for help
The dashboard: where every pair stands, how full each mentor is and which check-ins need a follow-up.

Privacy by design

Mentees never see other mentees, and nothing personal is on a public page: the reply and check-in pages open only with a signed link and show only that person’s own match. Contact details travel only after both sides say yes, and the whole process runs on your own server with no outside service.

How this differs from other pairing tools

  • Mentor Matching pairs two different groups of people, mentors and mentees, on what each side told you: shared topics and skills, language, industry, experience, availability and time zone. Every suggestion has a score out of 100 and the reasons behind it, mentors are never given more mentees than they offered to take, and each pair is introduced by e-mail and has to accept before contact details are shared. It then follows the pair with check-ins until the match ends.
  • Our Event Carpool Matching add-on matches drivers with free seats to passengers going the same way to an event. It is about rides: routes, pick-up points, seats and departure times. Mentor Matching is about people who will work together for weeks or months.
  • Our Random Pairing & Group Draw add-on makes random draws: secret gift exchanges, coffee roulette, random teams. Randomness is the point there. Mentor Matching does the opposite: it scores every possible pair on your criteria and suggests the best fit, and it explains why.
  • Our Team Skills Matrix add-on builds a grid of who in a team knows what, to spot gaps and plan training. It describes one team. Mentor Matching uses similar information (topics and skills) to connect people from two sides of a programme.
  • Gravity Forms on its own collects the mentor profiles and mentee applications as entries, but it cannot compare one form with another, score pairs, keep track of mentor capacity, introduce people or follow up.

Tips for a better programme

  • Keep the choice lists identical on both forms. Matching compares the text people choose, so “Data science” and “Data Science” match but “Analytics” does not.
  • Use must-match only for real deal-breakers. Every must-match rule shrinks the pool; weights are usually enough.
  • Start with a modest minimum score and raise it once you have enough mentors.
  • Watch the unmatched reasons after each round. They tell you exactly which mentor profiles to recruit next.
  • Read the check-ins that ask for help within a day or two. A quick nudge early saves most pairs.

Get started

The Gravity Forms Mentor Matching add-on works with Gravity Forms 2.9 and newer. Read the setup guide for every option, then build your two forms and run your first round of suggestions. See plans and pricing.

0
0
Your Cart
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
🔥 FREQUENTLY BOUGHT TOGETHER
Complete Combo & Save 40%!
ITEM IN YOUR CART
Gravity Forms Klaviyo Add-on
$39.00/yr
+
🎁 RECOMMENDED ADD-ON SAVE 40% OFF
Original Price: $39.00/yr
Bundle Special Price: $23.40/yr